Clay vs Concrete Tile
Clay Tile (Traditional)
- Cost: $800-$1,500 per square installed
- Lifespan: 75-100+ years
- Weight: 800-1,000 lbs per square (very heavy!)
- Benefits: Natural material, exceptional durability, won't fade, historic authenticity
Concrete Tile (More Common)
- Cost: $600-$1,000 per square installed
- Lifespan: 50-75 years
- Weight: 900-1,100 lbs per square
- Benefits: More affordable than clay, excellent durability, many color options
Tile Styles
- Spanish/Barrel Tile: S-shaped curved profile, classic Mediterranean look
- Flat/Slate Profile: Low-profile modern appearance, works with contemporary designs
- Double Roman: Alternating wide and narrow sections, elegant formal appearance
- Pantile: Gentle S-curve, traditional European farmhouse style
Advantages of Tile Roofing
Important Considerations
Structural Requirements (Critical!)
Tile is VERY heavy (800-1,100 lbs/square vs 200-400 lbs for asphalt). Your home's structure must support this weight:
- Professional structural engineer evaluation often required
- Roof framing may need reinforcement ($3,000-$10,000+)
- Not recommended for older homes without structural assessment
- Building codes may require additional support
Installation Requirements
- Experienced tile roofers essential (not all roofers work with tile)
- Proper underlayment critical for tile longevity
- Installation takes longer than asphalt (5-10 days)
- Cannot walk on tiles without breaking—requires planks
- Minimum 3:12 pitch required (some tiles need 4:12)
Energy Efficiency
Tile roofs excel in hot climates:
- Thermal mass absorbs heat during day, releases at night
- Natural air space under tiles provides ventilation
- Light colors reflect solar heat effectively
- Can reduce cooling costs by 20-30% in hot climates
- Ideal for southwestern and southern states
Cost Analysis
For typical 2,000 sq ft roof (20 squares):
- Concrete Tile: $18,000-25,000 installed
- Clay Tile: $22,000-35,000 installed
- Structural Reinforcement: $3,000-10,000 (if needed)
Despite high upfront costs, tiles can outlast 3-4 asphalt roofs (50-100 years vs 20-25 years each).
Maintenance
- Replace broken tiles promptly (individual tiles break if walked on)
- Clean moss/algae buildup (more common in humid climates)
- Inspect and maintain underlayment (may need replacement before tiles wear out)
- Keep gutters clean (tiles channel lots of water)
- Annual inspections recommended
Climate Considerations
Best Climates:
- Hot, sunny regions (Southwest, South, California)
- Moderate freeze-thaw cycles
- Areas with wildfire risk (tile is fire-proof)
Challenging Climates:
- Severe freeze-thaw cycles (water absorption can cause cracking)
- Areas with large hail (tiles can crack)
- High snow load regions (extreme weight concerns)
Is Tile Right for Your Home?
Tile roofing is ideal if:
- Your home has Spanish, Mediterranean, Mission, or Santa Fe architecture
- You live in a hot, sunny climate
- Your home structure can support the weight (engineering assessment)
- You want a lifetime roof solution
- You value distinctive, premium aesthetics
- HOA requires or encourages tile roofing
Consider alternatives if:
- Budget is limited (tile costs 2-3x asphalt)
- Home is older without structural reinforcement
- You live in area with severe freeze-thaw cycles
- Finding experienced tile roofers is difficult in your area
Frequently Asked Questions
Do tile roofs leak more than shingles?
No. When properly installed with quality underlayment, tile roofs are excellent at shedding water. The tiles themselves are waterproof.
Can I walk on my tile roof?
Individual tiles break under foot traffic. Professionals use walking boards. Avoid walking on your tile roof yourself.
How often do I need to replace tiles?
Rarely. Individual broken tiles can be replaced, but the bulk of tiles last 50-100 years. Underlayment may need replacement after 20-30 years.
Are all tile roofs terracotta colored?
No! Modern tiles come in many colors: terracotta, brown, gray, black, green, even custom colors. Concrete tiles offer the most color variety.
Considering Tile Roofing?
Get structural assessment and expert tile roofing quotes
Research Smarter. Decide Faster.
Compare material types, save the data to your inbox, discover vetted installers, and see how this roof performs at your ZIP code.
Compare Tile Roofing Types
Choose two configurations to see key differences instantly.
Option A
Option B
| Metric | Clay Tile | Concrete Tile |
|---|---|---|
| Installed Cost | $$$$ | $$$ |
| Expected Lifespan | 60-100 yrs | 40-60 yrs |
| Manufacturer Warranty | 50 yrs | 40 yrs |
| Wind Resistance | 150 mph | 140 mph |
| Impact Resistance | Class 4 | Class 4 |
| Best For | Mediterranean climates | Storm belts + HOA |
Email Me This Comparison
Save your selected options along with installer questions, color tips, and upgrade guidance.
- Includes Clay Tile vs Concrete Tile breakdown
- Printable checklist for bids
- Suggested questions for contractors
Delivered instantly as a PDF with next steps.
Material Durability Report
Enter your ZIP to see how tile roofing holds up in your climate.
Recommended Contractors
Top-rated crews that specialize in tile roofing installations.
Mission Tile Pros
Phoenix, AZ
Clay + concrete restorations
25+ yrs experience
Coastal Barrel Tile
Miami, FL
High-wind tie-down systems
19+ yrs experience
Sierra Tileworks
Los Angeles, CA
Lightweight composite tile
16+ yrs experience