Contractor Comparison Tool
Capture quotes, credentials, warranties, reviews, and red flags for every roofing contractor you interview. The tool ranks each bid instantly so you can make a confident decision.
Contractors Compared
0
Lowest Quote
—
Average Score
0%
Live Rankings
Higher score indicates better balance of value, reputation, and protection.
Add at least one contractor to see rankings.
Set Your Priorities
Adjust weighting to match what matters most.
Numbers do not need to total 100 — the tool normalizes automatically.
Comparison Matrix
Side-by-side look at the essentials.
| Contractor | Quote | Timeline | Warranty | Experience | Rating | Payment | Credentials |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contractor 1 | — | — | — | — | — | Deposit + progress draws | — |
| Contractor 2 | — | — | — | — | — | Deposit + progress draws | — |
| Contractor 3 | — | — | — | — | — | Deposit + progress draws | — |
Enter Contractor Details
Everything lives in one place—no more spreadsheets or sticky notes.
Contractor 1
Enter details to generate a score.
North Carolina or South Carolina license verified
General liability & workers comp on file
Provided at least three recent homeowners
Includes magnetic sweep, landscape protection, dumpsters
Physical address in your local area
Contractor 2
Enter details to generate a score.
North Carolina or South Carolina license verified
General liability & workers comp on file
Provided at least three recent homeowners
Includes magnetic sweep, landscape protection, dumpsters
Physical address in your local area
Contractor 3
Enter details to generate a score.
North Carolina or South Carolina license verified
General liability & workers comp on file
Provided at least three recent homeowners
Includes magnetic sweep, landscape protection, dumpsters
Physical address in your local area
Red Flags Detected
How to Use This Tool
Follow a simple, repeatable process.
- 1
Collect 3-5 detailed bids
Request the same scope (materials, underlayment, ventilation, cleanup).
- 2
Enter evidence
Plug in numbers, upload COIs, and capture notes from each conversation.
- 3
Review rankings + red flags
Adjust weights to see how priorities change the winner.
- 4
Decide with confidence
Lock in the contractor that balances price, expertise, and protection.
What to Compare
Scope & Pricing
- • Materials, underlayment, ventilation, flashing
- • Dumpster, cleanup, permits, warranty registration
- • Payment schedule and change-order process
- • Apples-to-apples inclusions for storm upgrades
Credentials
- • License class & bonding level
- • Insurance limits + expiration
- • Manufacturer certifications
- • Safety program & crew oversight
Reputation
- • Google & BBB reviews
- • Storm response track record
- • References from similar homes
- • Communication & transparency
Protection
- • Workmanship + material warranty terms
- • Leak response time and emergency service
- • Daily cleanup & property protection
- • Punch list walkthrough + documentation
Need a benchmark quote?
Add Top Guys Roofing to your comparison for a fully documented estimate, proof of insurance, and lifetime workmanship warranty options.